On December 6, 1975, Wesley Diggs came home to find his wife Jean and their four children — Audrey, 17; Allison, 16; Wesley Jr., 12; and Roger, 5 — shot dead inside their home at 266 Carlton Terrace in Teaneck, New Jersey. More than twenty rounds were fired. No one on the block heard a thing.

There was no forced entry. No sign of struggle. Nothing taken. The weapon was never recovered.

This is the largest unsolved mass homicide in Bergen County history. Fifty years later, the case file is still open.

In this episode: The last normal day. The crime scene. The weapon problem. The overnight window. And a father who walked into a silence that would follow him for the rest of his life.

—

SOURCES REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE:
• "Mother, 4 Children Are Shot to Death in Home in Teaneck" — The New York Times, December 7, 1975
• "Who Killed the Diggs Family?" — The Record (Bergen County, NJ), Jay Levin, December 6, 2015
• "5 Dead Family Members and Zero Answers" — NJ Advance Media / NJ.com, December 2025
• "Last Call: The Diggs Family Murder" — CrimeReads, 2021
• Bergen County Prosecutor's Office — case confirmed open
• The Amsterdam News — investigative reporting on the case

—

IF YOU HAVE INFORMATION:
The Bergen County Prosecutor's Office is still waiting.
Call: 201-226-5532

—

CONNECT:
Email: thelastthreadpodcast@gmail.com
Instagram: @thelastthreadpod
Twitter/X: @thelastthreadpod

—

The Last Thread is a true crime anthology podcast investigating cases that never got the attention they deserved. Hosted and produced by Web Pierre.

If this story stays with you the way it stayed with me — tell someone who'll listen.